Why Trying Harder to Sleep Makes Insomnia Worse and What to Do Instead

If you have ever been told to “just relax” about your sleep , or worse, to “stop stressing about it”, I understand why that advice felt useless. It is useless. Not because the sentiment is wrong, but because nobody told you how.

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, or ACT, is a well-researched psychological framework that offers something far more concrete. It is not about positive thinking. It is not about pretending everything is fine. And it is most definitely not about giving up on sleep.

It is about changing your relationship with the thoughts and feelings that are keeping you awake so they lose their grip, even when they are still present.

Where ACT Comes From

ACT was developed by psychologist Steven Hayes in the 1980s and sits within what researchers call the “third wave” of behavioral therapies. It has a substantial evidence base across anxiety, depression, chronic pain, and more recently, sleep disorders.

For insomnia specifically, ACT is used alongside or as a complement to Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I), which remains the gold standard first-line treatment for chronic insomnia. While CBT-I focuses heavily on restructuring sleep-disruptive behaviors and thoughts, ACT adds a layer of psychological flexibility, training you to relate differently to the internal experience of being awake, rather than trying to eliminate it.

Think of CBT-I as restructuring the house, and ACT as changing how you feel about being in it.

The Core Problem ACT Is Solving

Here is what happens in chronic insomnia: being awake becomes a threat. Not consciously, not rationally, but your nervous system has learned, through repetition, that lying awake at night means something is wrong. And so it responds accordingly, flooding you with adrenaline, racing thoughts, and a desperate urgency to fix the problem.

The harder you try to force sleep, the more you signal to your brain that this is, in fact, an emergency. Sleep, which is an involuntary biological process, not something you can execute through effort eludes you even more.

ACT targets this cycle at its root. The goal is not to think happy thoughts about being awake. The goal is to stop treating wakefulness as something that must be immediately escaped.

The Six Core Principles Applied to Sleep

ACT is built on six interconnected processes. Here is what each one means in the context of insomnia:

1. Acceptance

Acceptance is not resignation. It is the active, conscious decision to stop fighting your internal experience. When you lie awake and your mind says “I cannot be awake right now, this is a disaster,” acceptance means responding: “I am awake. This is uncomfortable. I do not have to make it stop in order to get through tonight.”

2. Defusion

Your thoughts are not facts. “I will never sleep again” is a thought, not a prognosis. Defusion is the practice of creating distance between you and your thoughts, noticing them as mental events rather than truths. Instead of “I will never sleep again,” defusion sounds like: “I am having the thought that I will never sleep again.” Small shift in language but a huge, psychological difference.

3. Present-Moment Awareness

Insomnia pulls you forward into catastrophe (“I have a big presentation tomorrow, I cannot function on no sleep”) and backward into pattern (“This is the fourth night in a row”). Present-moment awareness anchors you to what is actually happening right now, in this moment, not what happened last week or what might happen tomorrow.

4. Self-as-Context

You are not your insomnia. You are the person experiencing insomnia. This distinction sounds philosophical, but it is clinically meaningful. When patients say “I am an insomniac” that identity fusion makes recovery feel like a threat to the self. You are a whole person who is currently having difficulty sleeping. That is a very different starting point.

5. Values

When insomnia takes over, it tends to contract your life. You stop making plans because you might be exhausted. You pull back from things you love because you “need to protect your sleep.” ACT asks: what matters to you, independent of how you slept? Acting in alignment with your values, even imperfectly, even tired, keeps your world from shrinking around the insomnia.

6. Committed Action

This is where ACT moves from insight to behavior. Committed action means taking steps toward your values even when the internal experience is uncomfortable. Going to your child’s school event despite being exhausted. Maintaining your wake time even after a rough night. These are not punishments, they are acts of self-direction.

What ACT Is Not

A few things worth stating plainly, because I see these misconceptions often:

ACT is not a relaxation technique. It does not ask you to calm down or breathe your way through panic. It asks you to stop needing to.

ACT is not positive thinking. You are not replacing “I will never sleep” with “I will sleep great tonight.” You are learning that neither thought needs to run your night.

ACT is not a substitute for medical evaluation. If there is an underlying sleep disorder, sleep apnea, restless legs, a hormonal driver, no amount of psychological flexibility will resolve it. ACT is a tool within a comprehensive treatment plan, not a replacement for one.

How We Use ACT at The Restful Sleep Place

In my clinical work, ACT principles do not exist in a vacuum. They are integrated into a broader framework that starts with a thorough evaluation, ruling out or treating any physiological contributors first, and then building a behavioral and psychological plan tailored to the individual.

For women in midlife, this is especially important. The intersection of perimenopause, cortisol dysregulation, and conditioned arousal creates a picture that looks like “pure” insomnia but is actually layered. ACT helps with the psychological flexibility piece. But it works best when the hormonal and physiological context has been addressed alongside it.

My insomnia course walks you through the evidence-based framework, including ACT and CBT-I principles in a structured, self-paced format. It is designed for people who are in the middle of the struggle and want a real roadmap, not a list of sleep hygiene tips.

The goal of ACT is not to love being awake. It is to stop being at war with it. That shift from struggle to willingness is often what allows sleep to return. Not because you forced it, but because you finally stopped blocking it.


Dr. Funke Afolabi-Brown, MD, FAASM, is a triple board-certified sleep physician and bestselling author of Beyond Tired, and founder of The Restful Sleep Place in Horsham, PA. She specializes in sleep medicine for children, adults, and women in midlife. Follow her at @restfulsleepmd.

Next
Next

Can Andropause Affect My Sleep?